1961–1975 · P

Sam McDowell

6' 5", 190 lbs·Lived to 84·Bats L / Throws L

All-Star

The Almanac's Take

"Sudden Sam" could throw 100 mph when radar guns were still science fiction, and his 2,453 career strikeouts prove the folklore wasn't just Cleveland hype. McDowell's 1.81 ERA in 1968 — the Year of the Pitcher — ranked second only to Bob Gibson's legendary 1.60, making him the overlooked king of baseball's most dominant pitching season.

The numbers tell a story of brilliance constrained by command issues. McDowell averaged 8.86 strikeouts per nine innings for his career, a rate that would impress even in today's K-heavy game. His 283 strikeouts in 1968 led the American League, but 110 walks that same season hint at the wildness that kept him from true greatness.

Six All-Star selections and an ERA+ of 110 across 15 seasons represent sustained excellence, even if McDowell never quite harnessed his devastating fastball consistently enough to match the era's true aces like Gibson or Juan Marichal.

Career Highs

1.81

Best ERA · 1968

Most W · 1970

325

Most K · 1965

1.082

Best WHIP · 1968

Career Arc · OPS

12 seasons

Career Arc · ERA

14 seasons

Statistical Comps

Jake Arrieta

99%

2016 season

K/9 8.7 · BB/9 3.5 · HR/9 0.73 · SP · FB 94.3 mph · Whiff% 23

Aaron Nola

99%

2018 season

K/9 9.5 · BB/9 2.5 · HR/9 0.72 · SP · FB 92.4 mph · Whiff% 26

Zack Wheeler

99%

2018 season

K/9 8.8 · BB/9 2.7 · HR/9 0.69 · SP · FB 95.8 mph · Whiff% 22

Career · Hitting

15 seasons

Year	Team	G	AB	HR	RBI	AVG	OPS	OPS+
1961	CLE	1	2	0	0	.000	.000	—
1962	CLE	25	26	0	1	.154	.308	—
1963	CLE	15	19	0	0	.211	.461	—
1964	CLE	31	56	0	2	.143	.374	—
1965	CLE	43	95	0	4	.126	.272	—
1966	CLE	36	60	0	1	.200	.443	—
1967	CLE	37	82	1	6	.183	.422	—
1968	CLE	38	85	0	6	.153	.342	—
1969	CLE	39	92	0	6	.174	.379	—
1970	CLE	40	105	1	2	.124	.293	41
1971	CLE	35	73	0	4	.178	.367	54
1972	SF	28	59	0	4	.119	.303	46
1973	SF	34	12	0	0	.167	.333	47
1974	NYY	13	0	0	0	—	—	—
1975	PIT	14	8	0	0	.000	.000	0
Career		429	774	2	36	.154	—	—

Career · Pitching

15 seasons

Year	Team	G	IP	W	L	ERA	ERA+	SO	WHIP
1961	CLE	1	6.3	0	0	0.00	—	5	1.263
1962	CLE	25	87.7	3	7	6.06	65	70	1.722
1963	CLE	14	65.0	3	5	4.85	71	63	1.646
1964	CLE	31	173.3	11	6	2.70	133	177	1.431
1965	CLE	42	273.0	17	11	2.18	161	325	1.136
1966	CLE	35	194.3	9	8	2.87	123	225	1.194
1967	CLE	37	236.3	13	15	3.85	86	236	1.371
1968	CLE	38	269.0	15	14	1.81	165	283	1.082
1969	CLE	39	285.0	18	14	2.94	123	279	1.137
1970	CLE	39	305.0	20	12	2.92	133	304	1.203
1971	CLE	35	214.7	13	17	3.40	102	192	1.458
1972	SF	28	164.3	10	8	4.33	75	122	1.467
1973	NYY	34	135.7	6	10	4.11	91	110	1.555
1974	NYY	13	48.0	1	6	4.69	77	33	1.729
1975	PIT	14	34.7	2	1	2.86	129	29	1.442
Career		425	2492.3	141	134	—	—	2453	—

Ask The Almanac about Sam McDowell.

Matchups, projections, comps — grounded in Lahman, Retrosheet, and Statcast.

Start a conversation →