Travis Fryman

The five All-Star selections tell the story of sustained excellence rather than peak dominance. Fryman's 103 career OPS+ reflects a player who consistently delivered above-average offense while manning a premium defensive position. His 223 career home runs came during an era when third basemen were expected to hit for power, and he delivered without the gaudy numbers that defined the position's sluggers.

What separated Fryman was durability — 1,698 games across 13 seasons with just one year below 140 games played. In an era of flashier stars, he represented the backbone player every contending team needed.